03) QUICK ECONOMIC
TURNAROUND NOT IN THE
CARDS
(The
following
article is from the January 1-31, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the
source is credited. Subscription rates in Canada: $25/year, or $12 low
income rate; for U.S. readers - $25 US per year; other overseas readers
- $25 US or $35 CDN per year. Send to: People's Voice, c/o PV Business
Manager, 133 Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
By Kimball Cariou
The latest figures indicate that the
Canadian economy is becoming more deeply entrenched in recession, with
no recovery in sight.
Another
34,400 jobs were lost in
December, on top of 70,600 in November, for a two-month total of
105,000. The official unemployment rate hit 6.6%, the highest level in
three years.
But the
situation is worse than
these numbers, considering the sharper losses in full-time employment.
A shocking 70,700 full-time jobs disappeared in December, while
part-time jobs rose by 36,200.
The biggest
decline came in the
construction sector, where employment fell by 44,300, reflecting a
sharp decline in new homes and building starts.
Geographically, the December
figures show that the recession has begun to spread well beyond
Ontario, where the staggering loss of manufacturing jobs which began
several years ago has continued.
Looked at
another way, young
workers were hardest hit in December. For youths aged 15-24, net
employment figures fell by 36,600, and the jobless rate zoomed from
12.3% up to 12.9%.
"Today's
dismal data offer
additional strong evidence that the Canadian economy has quickly waded
knee-deep into recession," warned Douglas Porter, deputy chief
economist at BMO Capital Markets. Other "optimistic" mainstream
economists are forecasting that the jobless rate will hit 8% by
mid-year, followed by a recovery. Even this "best case scenario" would
see another 250,000 Canadian workers laid off by the summer, on top of
the 1.2 million already out of work.
Given the
Canadian economy's
tight links with the United States, things could get much worse. Early
figures confirm a sharp drop in US retail sales, as millions of working
people face unemployment. Total retail sales, excluding automobiles,
fell 8 percent in December through Christmas Eve over the same period
last year, according a report in the Globe and Mail. Sales for November
fell 5.5 percent. The sales declines are two to five times more severe
than most analysts expected. It is the first time that holiday sales
have fallen in the US in at least 40 years.
The holiday
numbers come a few
days after a Labor Department report showed that the number of US
workers filing for first-time unemployment benefits rose to a four-week
moving average of 558,000, the highest since November 1982. Wages for
US workers continue to deteriorate, leaving families even deeper in
consumer debt.
The end of
the winter shopping
season is also expected to result in a surge in layoffs. Retail stores
in the US already shed more than 90,000 jobs in November, and several
major firms have declared bankruptcy or begun liquidation (including
Circuit City, Linens `N Things, Steve & Barry's, and Mervyn's). In
another sign of bad news, sales of existing homes fell 8.6 percent in
December.
The top
economist at the
International Monetary Fund, Olivier Blanchard, told the French
newspaper Le Monde in early January that continued declines in consumer
spending would set off a global depression. "Consumer and business
confidence indexes have never fallen so far since they began. The
coming months will be very bad," he said. Echoing the right-wing view
that the crisis is largely psychological in origin, Blanchard said "It
is imperative to stifle this loss of confidence, to restart household
consumption, if we want to prevent this recession developing into a
Great Depression."
But this
"explanation" avoids
the basic reality of declining capitalist production. The US gross
domestic product fell 0.5 percent in the third quarter (July-September)
from the same period of 2007, but the fourth quarter decline is
predicted to hit a staggering 5 percent. Production in the other
advanced capitalist countries is also declining.
For example,
in Japan, the
second largest economy in the world, production fell by 8.1 percent
since October, the biggest such drop since the 1950s. The Japanese
Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry says its surveys show
manufacturers expected the decline to continue, with an 8.0 per cent
contracted forecast for January.
Other
countries are facing even
worse situations. In Ukraine, industrial production fell by a massive
28.6 percent in November, following a nearly 20 percent decline the
month before. In other words, nearly half of the country's industrial
production has been eliminated in the space of two months.
These
economies could be the
canaries in the mine shaft, if warnings from some economists are
correct. Foreign Policy magazine reported on Jan. 5 that "five
prominent economists who correctly predicted the 2008 world economic
meltdown say the crisis is only going to get worse."
New York
University economist
Nouriel Roubini, who correctly forecast the current disaster several
years ago, said the crisis is still in its early stages.
"As the U.S.
economy shrinks,
the entire global economy will go into recession. In Europe, Canada,
Japan and the other advanced economies, it will be severe. Nor will
emerging-market economies - linked to the developed world by trade in
goods, finance, and currency - escape real pain... The bubbles, and
there were many, have only begun to burst."
Roubini
predicted the U.S.
recession will last at least two years and could drag on for a decade.
He said hedge funds are being forced to sell their assets at fire-sale
prices while some financial institutions will go bust, and some
governments in emerging economies could default on their debt.
Morgan
Stanley Asia chairman
Stephen Roach said Asian economies will suffer from being overly
dependent on exports to the U.S. and on their own undervalued
currencies.
"A similar
verdict is likely for
the commodity-producing regions of the world, not just the
oil-dependent Middle East, but also the resource-intensive economies of
Australia, Canada, Brazil, Russia and Africa," Roach wrote. "As global
growth slows, so does the demand for economically sensitive
commodities, resulting in a sharp correction in the bubble-distorted
commodity prices and growth rates of the major commodity producers."
Yale
University economist Robert
J. Shiller, author of the 2008 book The Subprime Solution, was one of
several who cited the example of Japan.
"History
tells us there is some
precedent for a protracted, weak housing market. After the last housing
boom in the United States peaked in 1989, it took a typical city five
years to hit bottom," he wrote. "This time, prices have only been going
down for two years. We might look with caution to Japan, where urban
land prices fell for 15 consecutive years, from 1991 to 2006."