12) WHAT CAUSED THE
ECONOMIC CRISIS?
(The
following
article is from the March 1-15, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the
source is credited. Subscription rates in Canada: $25/year, or $12 low
income rate; for U.S. readers - $25 US per year; other overseas readers
- $25 US or $35 CDN per year. Send to: People's Voice, c/o PV Business
Manager, 133 Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
Excerpts
from the report of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of
Canada, Jan. 31-Feb. 1, 2009.
The most
significant development since our last meeting in August 2008 is the
deepening global economic crisis that had been maturing for several
years, but which erupted in force with the stock market crashes in
early October and which has been unfolding in the material (goods and
services) economy with ever-greater intensity and rapidity since. The
early signs of the impending crisis emerged in the US financial sector
in August 2007, but as predicted at our December 2007 CC meeting, it
soon grew to encompass the entire US and world capitalist economies. At
latest count, most of the leading capitalist countries - the U.S.,
Germany, Japan and Canada among them - are now `officially' in
recession, but even these statistics mask the universal breadth of the
global crisis.
No domestic
economy will be spared its devastating impact. Even the humming Chinese
economy is now sliding into a major downturn as exports plummet and
factories have begun laying off workers in the millions. The latest
International Labour Organization report has recently predicted global
job losses this year alone will exceed 50 million, but even this is
likely a conservative estimate. Third world economies will be
especially hard-hit as commodity prices plunge, global demand for
manufactured goods slumps, and as advanced capitalist countries cut
back on foreign aid and direct foreign investment.
In such a
situation all of the contradictions plaguing the global economy, and
social disparities within each of the countries, will be further
exacerbated. The working class, peasantry and the marginalized in the
poorer countries will be hardest hit because the `social safety net' in
such countries is much weaker or virtually nonexistent....
The
manifestations of the crisis are readily apparent everywhere; what is
critically important for the working class and for our Party however is
an understanding of its basic causes, its roots. Big Business interests
and their governments, and even reformists from the camp of social
democracy, have vested interests in keeping the real nature of the
crisis well hidden, because bringing the truth to light would lead
working people and other oppressed and exploited segments of the people
to question the very nature of the dominant system, and ultimately to
organize and fight for a fundamental socialist alternative to monopoly
capitalism, to imperialism.
If one were
to listen and believe the recent comments of, for instance, British
(Labour) Prime Minister Gordon Brown or U.S. President Barack Obama,
one would be led to conclude that the real culprits responsible for the
current economic meltdown are a handful of `irresponsible' bankers and
investment brokers. Naming a `fall guy' is a tried-and-true method to
steer the working class away from making a systemic critique of the
inner `boom and bust' workings of capitalism.
Cyclical
crises under capitalism are nothing new - they are in fact an inherent
and recurring feature of the capitalist mode of production. What
distinguishes the current crisis from previous ones are those features
which have come to play a dominant role in the process of capital
accumulation, in particular the role of speculative capital...
Governments
are not the only victims of spiralling debt. As we noted in December
2007, the prolongation of the `growth phase' leading up to the current
meltdown was achieved by maintaining mass consumption at artificially
high levels for a protracted period through the extension of more and
more paper credit. "What is new in the current situation is not the
extension of credit per se, but rather the scale of that credit
extension. This development reflects the increasingly parasitical
character of finance capitalism in today's world," our Central
Committee concluded.
Such
objective dynamics in the development of monopoly capitalism have been
in turn spurred on and exacerbated by the neoliberal policies pursued
by all the leading imperialist states. While they succeeded in the
short run in accelerating the accumulation of capital and overcoming
the general tendency, as Marx and Engels noted, for the rate of profit
to decline, the `debt bubble' and the growing gap between real and
paper wealth eventually had to give way. Other structural
contradictions of the systemic crisis of capitalism, such as increasing
and permanent militarization and the impact of environmental
degradation have combined to give rise to a `perfect storm,' as even
some bourgeois economists have come to describe it.
These
structural aspects of the systemic crisis of global capitalism are
staggering. Take the impact of growing militarization, for instance.
According to a report issued by the Stockholm International Peace
Research Institute, by 2006 world military expenditures had reached
$1,204 billion, a 37 per cent increase over the 10-year period since
1997. The USA was responsible for about 80 per cent of the increase and
its military expenditure now accounts for almost half of the world
total.
Add to this
the cost effect of environmental devastation. A recent World Wildlife
Fund study, The Living Planet, reports that every year 30% more
resources are being consumed than the Earth can replenish, which is
leading to deforestation, degraded soils, polluted air and water, and
dramatic declines in numbers of fish and other species. As a result, we
are running up an ecological debt of $4 - $4.5 trillion dollars every
year - double the estimated losses made by the world's financial
institutions as a result of the credit crisis. The figure is based on a
UN report which calculated the economic value of services provided by
ecosystems destroyed annually, such as diminished rainfall for crops or
reduced flood protection.
It is
therefore important to emphasize that the current crisis is not the
result of the implementation of neoliberal policies such as free trade,
deregulation, privatization, and anti-labour employment policies, etc.;
rather, it is the inevitable outcome of the systemic crisis of
capitalism itself. That said, distortions wrought by neoliberal policy
have certainly intensified the reach and severity of the global crisis.
(Next issue: different approaches to addressing the crisis.)