09) BUSH FREE TO
ENTER, GALLOWAY BARRED
(The
following
article is from the April 1-15, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the
source is credited. Subscription rates in Canada: $25/year, or $12 low
income rate; for U.S. readers - $25 US per year; other overseas readers
- $25 US or $35 CDN per year. Send to: People's Voice, c/o PV Business
Manager, 133 Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
By Johan Boyden, General Secretary,
Young Communist League of Canada
On one side of Canada stood a man who, for my generation, personifies
the great evil of the US empire. On March 17 he was warmly welcomed to
Calgary by the governing Harper Conservatives. From outside the
$400‑plate luncheon of business and oil executives, over 200 protestors
chanted, expressing the sentiments of the Canadian people.
On the other side of the country well over a
thousand people - in
Toronto, Ottawa, and Montreal - had pulled $10 out of their wallets to
hear an outspoken anti‑war crusader. On March 20, this man was banned
from entering Canada for posing a threat to national security.
The first case is George W Bush. If what
resonates with the
Canadian people had been recognized in Ottawa, then the clarion call
contained in a letter from Lawyers Against the War to the RCMP would
have been heard. Bush would have been arrested for crimes against
humanity. He was not.
The second case is rebel British MP George
Galloway, a mighty and
eloquent speaker. Galloway, who left Britain's Labour party in 2003 and
now sits as a left‑wing Respect MP, has hurled repeated barrages of
verbal criticism against the oppression and injustice of US, Israeli,
British, and Canadian foreign policy. For this he has been censured.
People's Voice readers already know the answer to the question: will
this public outcry resonate with the Canadian government?
If you don't know who Galloway is, search his
name and "Senate
hearing" on You Tube to hear him speak. He is the man who famously
crossed the Atlantic to address a US Senate hearing that had falsely
accused him of corruption:
"I gave my heart and soul to stop you
committing the disaster
which you did commit in Iraq. And I told the world that your case for
the war was a pack of lies... Senator, in everything I said, about
Iraq, I turned out to be right and you turned out to be wrong. And a
hundred thousand people have paid with their lives, sixteen hundred of
them American soldiers, sent to their deaths, on a pack of lies."
George Galloway has been to Canada before. In
2006, he told CBC's
George Stroumboulopoulos that "your foreign policy has changed markedly
even in the twelve months or so since I was last here, it has a
sharper, uglier edge."
Apparently the Harper Conservative government
cannot handle such criticism, or any at all.
It was entirely appropriate that an emergency
planning session
responding to Galloway's ban came at the end of a three‑day student
anti‑war conference in Toronto - a meeting talking about issues from
the increasingly aggressive military recruitment campaigns to the
carbon footprint of NATO.
The emergency session heard numerous reports
of similar
clamp-downs on freedom of speech. High school teachers and students
with the Coalition Against Israeli Apartheid spoke of the heavy‑handed
approach of the Toronto School Board and university administrations
(reported in our last issue). The War Resistors have seen four
resistors and young families deported by Immigration Minister Jason
Kenney's department. The Canadian Arab Federation's funding is being
cut by Kenney not because of any action, but a political statement.
"We have to funnel the outrage of the Canadian
public towards
Harper," Toronto Coalition to Stop the War spokesperson James Clark
said. The group is launching a legal challenge led by Barbara Jackman.
If that doesn't work a delegation of Canadian MPs, lawyers and
activists will escort Galloway across the border from the US.
The burning issue here is freedom of speech -
even Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff gets that.
Galloway joins a growing list of progressives
not allowed into
Canada, from US women's peace activists with Code Pink, to William
Ayers and anti‑war folk musician David Rovics, and hip hop artist
Immortal technique. Nor were they the first.
As Galloway himself said: "More than half a
century ago Paul
Robeson, one of the greatest men who ever lived, was forbidden to enter
Canada not by Ottawa but by Washington, which had taken away his
passport. But he was still able to transfix a vast crowd of Vancouver's
mill hands and miners with a 17‑minute telephone concert, culminating
in a rendition of the Ballad of Joe Hill. Technology has moved on since
then. And so from coast to coast, minister Kenney notwithstanding, I
will be heard ‑ one way or another."