01) ECONOMIC TRUTHS
COUNTER "RECOVERY"
MYTH
(The following
article is from the September 16-30, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist
newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the source is credited.
Subscription rates in Canada: $30/year, or $15 low income rate; for
U.S. readers - $45 US per year; other overseas readers - $45 US or $50
CDN per year. Send to:
People's Voice, c/o PV Business Manager, 133
Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
Special to PV
Cheery headlines about the
"recovery" continue to pop up almost daily, but a closer look at the
news tells a rather different story for working people.
The actual
US unemployment rate would be reported at 16 percent if persons who
have dropped out of the labour pool and those working less than they
would like are counted, according to a US Federal Reserve official.
Dennis
Lockhart, told an Aug. 26 Chamber of Commerce event in Chattanooga,
Tennessee, that "If one considers the people who would like a job but
have stopped looking - so-called discouraged workers - and those who
are working fewer hours than they want, the unemployment rate would
move from the official 9.4 percent to 16 percent." Lockhart was
expressing his own views, which "do not necessarily reflect those of my
colleagues on the Federal Open Market Committee," the policy-setting
body of the central bank.
But
Lockhart's blunt statement is far more revealing about the state of the
global economy than any number of starry-eyed commentaries which fill
the corporate media these days.
"My forecast
for a slow recovery implies a protracted period of high unemployment,"
Lockhart said, adding that it would be difficult to stimulate jobs
through additional public spending.
"Further fiscal stimulus has been
mentioned, but the full effects of the first stimulus package are not
yet clear, and the concern over adding to the federal deficit and the
resulting national debt is warranted."
Construction
and manufacturing have been particularly hard hit in the U.S. recession
that began in December 2007, and some jobs are considered "gone for
good." Prior to the recession, these two sectors accounted for slightly
more than 15 percent of US jobs. But losses in these industries during
the present crisis have made up more than 40 percent of all US job
losses.
Lockhart's
bleak outlook is shared by Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph
Stiglitz, who warned again recently that the country may face a
"double-dip" recession. Given the massive impact of the US economy on
Canada, the "recovery" in this country is fragile and likely very
short-lived at best.
Stiglitz, a
former World Bank chief economist, said in early September that "the
prospects of a robust recovery are very, very weak". He said there was
a "significant chance" that the economy could contract again after a
period of growth, since "we are not seeing a recovery of sustained
consumption."
Stiglitz
highlighted the fact that any recovery would be the result of
government stimulus packages, which cannot continue indefinitely. "The
withdrawal of stimulus packages in 2011 will be a negative shock to the
economy," he said.
The global
crisis has had a particularly negative impact on youth, according to a
United Nations study which reports that young people make up about 25
per cent of the world's working population, but account for 40 per cent
of the unemployed.
"For the
young" UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said about the report,
"informal, insecure and low-wage employment is the norm, not the
exception."
A record
201,000 young Canadians are among those out of work, or one in five
members of the workforce of 18- to 24-year-olds. Again, that figure
does not include so-called "discouraged workers", or it might be at
least 100,000 higher.
In Britain,
about a million youth are unemployed, leading the Economist magazine to
editorialize that the "plight of the jobless young ... invokes talk of
a lost generation... (P)rolonged unemployment early in people's working
lives will leave them scarred in the long term. Youngsters who have
been jobless for a year or more tend to do worse in the labour market
for the rest of their lives."
As the
global recession set in last year, Canadian youth joblessness of 11.6
per cent of the 15- to 24-year-old labour force was a bit lower than
the average for the 30 industrial nations of the Organization for
Economic Cooperation and Development. But job prospects for Canadian
youth trailed those of the Netherlands, Japan, Denmark, Australia and
South Korea, which have more comprehensive government-subsidized
training and work-placement programs.
In total,
nearly 500,000 more Canadians were unemployed this Labour Day than
last. Job losses are expected to rise well into next year, and many of
those who have lost their jobs either don't qualify for Employment
Insurance, or will soon run out of EI benefits.
"People that
can't collect EI are being forced to go on welfare, which is driving
them further into poverty," said Canadian Labour Congress president Ken
Georgetti.
Those who
still have jobs are working harder than ever. A survey conducted in
July by Harris-Decima, and commissioned by Everest College, found the
recession is having a serious impact on workers, with over one-third
saying that work "dominates" their life. Almost 25 per cent of
Canadians are working more than one job to make ends meet, and an equal
number expected to work during the Labour Day weekend, said Don
Thibert, director of academic affairs at Everest.