07) BC BUDGET UPDATE: A
DELIBERATELY MISLEADING DOCUMENT
(The following
article is from the September 16-30, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist
newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the source is credited.
Subscription rates in Canada: $30/year, or $15 low income rate; for
U.S. readers - $45 US per year; other overseas readers - $45 US or $50
CDN per year. Send to:
People's Voice, c/o PV Business Manager, 133
Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
Commentary by
Kimball Cariou
The "budget
update" introduced to the BC Legislature on Sept. 1 is a carefully
crafted political document, designed to reassure a worried public that
"core" services are being protected and that taxes on low and
middle-income earners are not being increased. But the depth of anger
against the Campbell Liberals will be on display on Sept. 19, during a
rally in Vancouver against the government's plan to "harmonize" federal
and provincial sales taxes.
With its
$2.8 billion deficit, this "update" is wildly different than the
figures Finance Minister Colin Hansen presented just months ago.
Hansen's earlier budget projected a mere $500 million deficit, despite
ample evidence that the BC economy was deeply mired in the crisis which
has shrunk government revenues in many countries. At that time, the
Campbell Liberal government sought to present an image of fiscal
reliability heading into the May 12 provincial election.
That was
then, this is now. Shortly after narrowly winning the election, the
Liberals "learned the truth" - revenues were falling faster than rocks
down a mine shaft. In April and May, the Liberals called the
"harmonised sales tax" the worst possible economic policy for the
province; by June, Campbell and Hansen announced that the HST was just
the medicine BC needs. Their new-found enthusiasm for the "hated sales
tax" apparently has much to do with the federal Tory government's bribe
of $1.6 billion to implement this shift, which will create a 12% sales
tax on a much wider range of goods and services next July 1. Looked at
from a broader perspective, right-wing governments at both the federal
and provincial levels are keen to complete the switch to the HST, which
will move billions from the pocketbooks of working people to the bank
accounts of corporations.
But Harper's
HST bribe is dwarfed by the size of BC's economic woes, as seen by the
$2.8 billion deficit now projected for the 2009-10 fiscal year, and
billions more to come.
A virtual
blizzard of cutback announcements has been issued from Victoria.
Cabinet ministers have resorted to often contradictory explanations, as
line-item cuts are dictated by Finance officials after virtually no
consultation with other government departments.
The budget
update confirmed more than $300 million in cuts to front-line health
care, including surgeries, seniors' programs, diagnostic and pharmacy
services, residential care, health records, mental health services and
other critical services. While services are slashed, British Columbians
will pay more than $100 million in Medical Service Plan premium
increases, and health authorities will have to absorb the increased
premiums on their payroll costs.
School
boards across B.C. will also have to cover MSP costs for their
employees. But Boards were even more shocked by the elimination of
annual facilities grants announced last spring for the current budget
year. Totalling over $100 million for the province, the grants help pay
for maintenance of buildings and classrooms. Much of this money had
already been spent by Boards doing such work over the summer. In the
case of Vancouver, a $10 million cut will cost dozens of jobs, and
leaves many students and teachers going back to classrooms where
important improvements have not been completed.
In the
longer term, the budget crisis is seen by the Campbell government as a
unique opportunity to advance its full right-wing agenda. As
negotiations loom for most public sector unions, the Liberals are eager
to impose pay freezes and cuts on provincial employees, with a wider
negative impact on all workers in B.C. The Liberal "P3" strategy,
already well underway in recent years, will also gain momentum, as the
government argues that the private sector must take an ever larger role
in building new infrastructure and seizing larger chunks of public
services.
Much of the
opposition to this strategy will be seen at the "Stop the HST" rally,
12 noon, Saturday, September 19, at the Convention Centre in downtown
Vancouver. Built as a P3, the Centre is a prime example of public
dollars to subsidize big business; the cost of the project doubled to
nearly $1 billion before completion last spring.
Reflecting
the breadth of anger against the Liberals, the Sept. 19 rally will be
chaired by Bill Vander Zalm, the former Socred premier who has opposed
Campbell on such issues as Hydro privatization. The labour movement and
progressive social movements will be out in large numbers, helping to
turn the event from a purely anti-tax rally into a wider demonstration
for a shift away from the Liberal right-wing agenda for British
Columbia.