04) EXPLOITATION SOARS,
UNEMPLOYMENT JUMPS!
(The following
article is from the December 1-31, 2009, issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist
newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the source is credited.
Subscription rates in Canada: $30/year, or $15 low income rate; for
U.S. readers - $45 US per year; other overseas readers - $45 US or $50
CDN per year. Send to:
People's Voice, c/o PV Business Manager, 133
Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
By Zoltan Zigedy, from http://www.mltoday.com
This sure is some recovery! The first
week in November brought remarkable results for an economy widely held
to be on the mend. Earnings of corporations are on the rise, the stock
market is perking up, and the Administration is claiming credit for
pulling the economy back from the brink and setting it well on the
course to health.
But in the
other world, the
world outside of Wall Street, gated communities, and the political
elite, the news is catastrophic, pushing the misery index dramatically
higher.
The rate of
exploitation [of
U.S. workers], as measured by output per hour of labour has increased
by 9.6% in the third quarter of this year, more than four times its
average growth over the last 25 years. This increase comes on the heels
of a 6.9% rise in the second quarter.
Put simply,
these numbers mean
that for every worker engaged in some form of productive activity, on
average, he or she produced almost 10% more in the third quarter of
this year over the same quarter last year. Intuitively, this means that
the capitalist system has squeezed another dollar in value from workers
who produced ten dollars in value last year. Or, put another way, for
every hour of labour, workers were forced to do 10% more productive
work.
Some might
respond that it
doesn't follow that workers necessarily worked harder for these
productivity gains. That may well be true in some cases, but we have
other Labour Department data that bear on this matter. We also know
that total employment is on the decline. In addition, the Labour
Department reports that the hours worked were down again for the ninth
straight quarter. Combine that fact with a 4% rise in output, and it's
pretty clear that workers were squeezed harder.
Capitalist
apologists would be
quick to point out - and they always do - that other factors may
contribute to productivity increases besides worker effort such as
technological innovations and investment in more efficient equipment
and techniques. This response evaporates in the face of the dramatic
decline in investment brought on by the broad economic crisis.
Of course it
would be possible
that workers worked harder because they wanted to make more money,
producing more because they wanted to earn a commensurately larger
compensation. This, however, is belied by the fact that unit labour
costs were down 5.2% in the third quarter: every unit of value produced
earned the workers 5.2% less than it did in the third quarter of 2008.
We have then
a stubborn fact:
workers worked a lot harder most of this year than they did last year
with a smaller share of the value produced.
This
stubborn fact goes
unacknowledged and unexplained. It will not be discussed on the Sunday
morning talk shows. The media - from The New York Times to the organs
of the labour movement - will pass over this fact, often hailing it as
a harbinger of recovery. Academic and working economists assign it no
special place, no event of great consequence.
It is only
in the Marxist
tradition that this fact occupies a central role and is properly
explained. In fact, it is the fundamental notion in the political
economy of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, exposing the primary
mechanism of profit generation in the capitalist mode of production. In
the end, they argued, increases in the rate of profit come from workers
getting a smaller portion of the product of their labour. They labelled
this measure the rate of exploitation. From the Marxist perspective,
the capitalist class intensifies exploitation - raises its rate - to
restore or increase the rate of profit. Indeed, this is axiomatic in
the Marxist system.
While
mainstream economists
strain to explain the rise in profits and the stock market in the face
of climbing unemployment and slack consumption, they refuse to attend
to the role of labour exploitation in this development.
In our time,
this sharp increase in labour exploitation signals two disturbing
truths:
1. The relative strength and
privilege of capital. Monopoly capital wields sufficient power,
unrestrained by the organs of popular sovereignty - the government, to
extract dramatically more effort from the working class.
2. The relative weakness of labour.
The labour movement lacks sufficient strength, determination, or
government influence to at the very least retain a proportionate share
of the product of its efforts.
Thus, the
burden of the capitalist recovery - profits and stock equity
values is borne squarely by the working class.
(In Part 2 of this article, to
appear in our next issue, the author examines the impact of rising
unemployment on U.S. working people.)