09) CANADA SHOULD MAKE
DOW ACCOUNTABLE
(The following
article is from the January 1-15, 2010 issue of People's Voice,
Canada's
leading communist
newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the source is credited.
Subscription rates in Canada: $30/year, or $15 low income rate; for
U.S. readers - $45 US per year; other overseas readers - $45 US or $50
CDN per year. Send to:
People's Voice, c/o PV Business Manager, 133
Herkimer St., Unit 502, Hamilton, ON, L8P 2H3.)
By Gurpreet Singh
As Canada gears up for the Winter
Olympics 2010, activists involved in helping the victims of Bhopal -
the worst incident in the history of industrial disasters in India -
have stepped up their campaign against the US-based Dow Chemical
company.
In December
1984, there was a
massive gas leak at the Union Carbide pesticide plant in Bhopal,
instantly killing about 5,000 people. The number of the dead later rose
to 20,000. Union Carbide is now owned by Dow Chemical, one of the
official corporate sponsors of the 2010 Olympics.
Union
Carbide CEO Warren
Anderson was charged and arrested for the deaths in India, but was
allowed to flee the country back to the United States.
The
activists who are helping
the victims families and those who became visually impaired for the
rest of their lives organized a candle light vigil in Vancouver on
December 3 to mark the 25th anniversary of the episode. The vigil was
held not only to draw the attention of the world to the sufferings of
the victims, but also to seek a ban on Dow from the Olympics.
Satinath
Sarangi, the prominent
leader of the Bhopal victims, who visited Vancouver a few years ago,
had asked the Canadian government not to let Dow Chemical to
participate in the event. Likewise, Rachna Dhingra who earlier worked
for Dow and is now working with the victims of the Bhopal tragedy,
feels that the company is both legally and morally responsible to fix
the problem after buying Union Carbide, and should clean the water
system in the affected area. According to several studies, the
underground water of Bhopal is still contaminated.
The Bhopal
activists feel that
the Indian establishment lacks the will to get Anderson extradited from
the USA and to make Dow Chemical accountable. Both the ruling Congress
party and the right-wing opposition BJP have accepted favours from Dow,
which is also accused of bribing Indian officials. India's Central
Bureau of Investigation is probing the matter. India's Ambassador to
the USA, Meera Shankar, has named Dow Chemical among other companies
which reportedly paid bribes to Indian ministries and staff.
At the time
of the mishap,
Madhya Pradesh province, where Bhopal city is located, was governed by
the Congress. The government did nothing to relocate the Union Carbide
plant despite warnings of a possible disaster. T.R. Chauhan, the former
plant operator and the author of Bhopal: The inside story believes the
company was also involved in cost cutting measures and possibly
compromised safety. He also says that Union Carbide and Dow are
involved in double standards, as they have been more careful towards
public safety in the USA, but do not care when it comes to the safety
of the people of a poor country like India.
Twenty-five
years later, the BJP
government of the province tried to underplay the issue by claiming
that the drinking water of the city is clean. Apart from facing the
allegations of protecting Dow, the two big national political parties
should also take blame for recklessly opening the doors to foreign
investors at the cost of peoples' life and liberty.
Rachna
Dhingra alleges that Dow
is one of the donors to the BJP, while the company is represented by a
lawyer aligned with the Congress Party. How the rich multinational
companies get away by befriending the political forces in developing
and poor countries can be understood from the Bhopal episode. Not only
has the Indian government failed to press the USA to hand over Warren
Anderson, but a meagre compensation has been paid to the victims.
Canada can
at least make Dow
answerable be cancelling its Olympic sponsorship. Prime Minister
Stephen Harper, who recently visited India to improve trade relations
with that country, should intervene to get justice for the victims of
the tragedy. A national daily of India, The Hindu, has already set an
example by cancelling the associate sponsorship of Dow Chemical for its
Friday Review November Fest 2009.